Current listings from OneKey MLS, plus straight answers from a local broker whose office is on N Greene Ave.
Looking for a home in Lindenhurst? Browse current listings and reach out to Laura Cawley, Principal Broker of Montauk Dunes Real Estate and a lifelong Lindenhurst resident. Whether you're looking near the village downtown, close to the LIRR, or along the waterfront, Laura can help you compare properties, set up listing alerts, and schedule showings.
Laura Cawley, Principal Broker, Montauk Dunes Real Estate LLC • Licensed New York State Real Estate Broker • 646-234-2160
To see Lindenhurst homes, tap Filters in the search below, enter 11757 in the Zip box, and set your price and bedrooms. Searching by ZIP picks up homes in the village and in North Lindenhurst. Want to see something in person? Call 646-234-2160 or send your search details.
Search not loading? Open the listing search in a new window.
A Lindenhurst mailing address doesn't tell you which local government a house is in. The ZIP code 11757 covers the incorporated Village of Lindenhurst and unincorporated parts of the Town of Babylon, mainly the hamlet of North Lindenhurst, plus some addresses that are technically in Copiague or West Babylon. The Town of Babylon has a page with real address examples showing how this works.
| Village of Lindenhurst | North Lindenhurst | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Incorporated village with its own government | Hamlet in the Town of Babylon, no village government |
| Who handles permits and code | Village of Lindenhurst | Town of Babylon |
| Tax layers | Village tax on top of town, county, school, and district taxes | No village tax; town, county, school, and district taxes |
| Mailing address | Lindenhurst, NY 11757 | Usually Lindenhurst, NY 11757 |
Why this matters to you as a buyer: two houses a few blocks apart can have different tax bills and different building departments. If a house has a finished basement, an addition, or a newer deck, the permit history needs to come from the right office. Ask us to pull the jurisdiction for any address you're serious about, or confirm it with the Town of Babylon Assessor.
School district and fire district boundaries don't always follow the village line either. If either one matters to you, confirm it for the specific address with the district directly.
The tax number on a listing is a starting point, not your future bill. Before you compare two Lindenhurst homes on taxes, check these:
If you send us two or three addresses you're weighing, we'll help you line up the tax picture for each one.
South of Montauk Highway, Lindenhurst is built around canals that lead out to the Great South Bay. A canal-front home with a dock is a big part of the appeal here, and flood insurance is a big part of the cost. Get answers to these questions before you go to contract, not after:
This is general information for buyers, not insurance or legal advice. Your insurance agent and attorney should review the specific property.
North of Montauk Highway, residential streets lead into the downtown around Wellwood and Hoffman Avenues, with local shops, restaurants, and the Lindenhurst LIRR station. South of Montauk Highway, the neighborhoods shift toward the canals and the Great South Bay. Most buyers we work with know which side they want after a couple of showings. Tell us how you'll actually use the house, and we'll point you to the streets that fit.
Selling a home in Lindenhurst too? See our Lindenhurst real estate page for recent sales and a free home value report, or read our first-time homebuyer guide for Long Island.
No. A Lindenhurst mailing address can be inside the incorporated Village of Lindenhurst or in an unincorporated hamlet of the Town of Babylon, including North Lindenhurst and parts of Copiague and West Babylon. Confirm the jurisdiction for a specific address with the Town of Babylon Assessor before you make an offer.
Not necessarily. Exemptions such as STAR, senior, and veterans exemptions belong to the current owner and may not carry over to you. Ask for the actual tax bill and a list of exemptions on the property, then estimate your own taxes without them.
Often, yes. A National Flood Insurance Program policy can be assigned to a new owner, which can keep existing discounts in place. Ask the seller for the current declarations page early and have your insurance agent compare it with a new quote before you go to contract.
Yes. Fill out the form below with your price range and must-haves, or call 646-234-2160, and Laura will set up a search that sends you new Lindenhurst listings as they hit OneKey MLS.
Tell us what you're looking for and Laura will set up a OneKey MLS search that emails you new Lindenhurst listings as they come on the market. You'll hear back personally within one business day.